| Clinical situation | Often favored procedure logic |
|---|---|
| Severe GERD / Barrett esophagus | RYGB often favored; sleeve may worsen reflux |
| Very high BMI / severe diabetes | RYGB or BPD/DS considered depending on risk/compliance |
| Need simpler operation / avoid bowel bypass | Sleeve gastrectomy often chosen |
| High nutritional non-adherence risk | Avoid highly malabsorptive procedures |
| Previous abdominal surgery | Individualized; adhesions may influence approach |
| Procedure | Mechanism | Main advantage | Main concern |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sleeve gastrectomy | Restriction + hormonal | Common, simpler, no bypass | GERD, irreversible, leak |
| RYGB | Restriction + mild malabsorption + metabolic | Diabetes/GERD benefit, strong weight loss | Internal hernia, dumping, deficiencies |
| BPD/DS | Restriction + marked malabsorption | Strongest weight/metabolic effect | Highest nutritional/protein deficiency risk |
| Gastric band | Restriction | Reversible | Less used; slippage/erosion/reoperation |